Win 100% unexpected cashback
LEARN HOW *T's and C's apply
Back
Insurance

NZ Life Insurance Companies Compared

This is a personal question that depends on individual circumstances. LifeDirect provides factual information and comparisons to help people understand their options. Life insurance companies in New Zealand all make the same basic promise, but no single one suits everyone. The right fit depends on your age, health, job and what you need covered.

What you can compare is each insurer's claims record, financial strength, policy features and price. In their latest published years, NZ life insurers reported paying between about 91% and 97% of claims. At LifeDirect, we compare eight NZ insurers side by side, so you can see which suits you.

Key facts

  • NZ life insurers reported paying between about 91% and 97% of claims in their latest published years, each measured in its own way.
  • AIA paid $790 million in claims in 2025, the largest total of the insurers shown here, and accepted 91% of the claims it received.
  • Partners Life's parent company has agreed to buy Fidelity Life. As at November 2026 the deal was awaiting regulator approval.
  • Financial strength ratings come from different agencies with different scales, so they can't be compared directly.
  • From 2020 to 2025, LifeDirect clients were paid more than $51 million across more than 2,200 successful claims.

In This Article

Want to see how the insurers compare for you? Get quotes from eight NZ insurers in a few minutes.

Get Quotes

How Do NZ Life Insurance Companies Compare?

NZ life insurance companies can be compared on four things: their claims record, financial strength, policy features and price. The larger insurers publish claims figures each year, and most reported paying between about 91% and 97% of claims in their latest published year. Those figures are measured differently, so they're a guide rather than a ranking.

Insurer Claims paid Claims accepted Period
AIA $790m 91% of claims received 2025
Partners Life More than $325m 95% of claims assessed Year to March 2025
Fidelity Life $247.7m 93% of new claims Year to June 2025
Asteron Life $112m 97% of claims received Year to June 2024
Chubb Life Not stated 95% of claims 2025

Figures are as published by each insurer, for the period shown.

  • AIA — New Zealand's largest life insurer, known for its AIA Vitality rewards programme.
  • Partners Life — founded in New Zealand and sold through advisers. Japan's Dai-ichi Life has owned it since 2022, and its parent has agreed to buy Fidelity Life.
  • Fidelity Life — New Zealand's largest locally owned life insurer until its sale completes.
  • Asteron Life — set to take on Resolution Life's NZ policies and be renamed Acenda Life in 2027, subject to approval.
  • Chubb Life — known as Cigna in New Zealand until 2023.

Other insurers selling life cover in New Zealand include nib, Southern Cross Life and Pinnacle Life. If you're new to how cover works, start with what life insurance is.

How to Read Life Insurers' Claims Figures

Claims figures aren't a like-for-like ranking. Insurers count claims differently, as claims received, assessed or new, and report over different years. Dollar totals mostly reflect size, because a bigger insurer usually pays more in total. An acceptance rate is a useful signal, but it can't tell you how a particular policy would treat your claim.

  • Different counting — "claims received", "claims assessed" and "new claims" aren't the same base.
  • Different years — some insurers report by calendar year, others to March or June.
  • Size, not quality — a bigger insurer with more customers will usually pay more in total.
  • Product mix — some figures include health, trauma and income cover, not just life cover.

Based on LifeDirect's claim statistics for 2020 to 2025, LifeDirect clients were paid $40.3 million through AIA across 2,175 claims, $7.36 million through Asteron across 47 claims and $3.66 million through Fidelity Life across 37 claims. These figures reflect where our clients' policies sit, not a ranking of insurers. See the full breakdown in our claim statistics.

Why the Right Life Insurer Depends on You

Every life insurer makes the same basic promise, but each prices it differently and adds different features. An insurer that's good value for a healthy 30-year-old may not be the most affordable at 50, or the most flexible if you have a health condition. So the more useful question is which insurer suits you, at your age, with your health.

Your job, hobbies and smoking status also affect price and terms, and each insurer weighs them in its own way. Read more on how different options affect your life insurance premium.

See which insurers suit your age and health. Compare quotes side by side, or talk to a licensed adviser for free.

Compare quotes

What Matters More Than the Brand?

When people compare life insurers, the details of the policy usually matter more than the name on it. How the policy defines conditions decides whether a claim is paid. The terms you're offered for your health, the price for your age and cover, and the help you get at claim time all shape what the cover is worth to you.

  • Definitions — how the policy defines conditions such as cancer or disability decides whether a claim is paid.
  • Your terms — one insurer may offer standard terms while another adds an exclusion or charges more for the same health history.
  • Price — the same cover can cost quite different amounts for your age and cover level.
  • Extras — features such as a terminal illness benefit or rewards programmes like AIA Vitality.
  • Claim support — having someone on your side at a hard time makes a real difference.

For more on one of the most common extras, see terminal illness and life insurance cover.

Price for your age and cover

Based on LifeDirect client data for policies put in force from January 2025 to September 2026, a non-smoker aged 35 to 44 typically pays about $30 a month for $500,000 of stepped life cover. Prices for the same cover vary between insurers, which is why comparing quotes for your own details matters.

The type of premium makes a difference too. Stepped premiums usually rise each year with age, while level premiums stay the same for a set time. See stepped or level premiums for how they compare over time.

Want real prices for your age and cover? Run a free quote and compare eight NZ insurers in one place.

Get a quote

What Do Financial Strength Ratings Tell You?

A financial strength rating is an independent agency's view of an insurer's ability to pay claims over time. Licensed New Zealand insurers generally must have a rating and disclose it. Ratings come from agencies such as AM Best, Fitch and S&P, each with its own scale, so a rating from one agency can't be compared directly with another.

  • Asteron Life — A+ (Strong), Fitch.
  • Partners Life — A (Excellent), AM Best.
  • Fidelity Life — A- (Excellent), AM Best.
  • Southern Cross Life — A+ (Strong), S&P.

A rating shows financial strength, not price or policy features. Insurers are licensed and supervised by the Reserve Bank of New Zealand. Read more in insurance company financial strength ratings.

What Happens at Claim Time?

At claim time, the insurer assesses the claim against the policy wording and the information given when you applied. A claim often comes at a hard time, such as after a death in the family or a serious diagnosis, so it helps to know who will support you. With an adviser, someone can help with the forms, evidence and follow-ups.

See how LifeDirect advisers can make claim time easier.

If you're unhappy with a decision, you can use the insurer's complaints process and then a free dispute resolution scheme, such as the Insurance & Financial Services Ombudsman or Financial Services Complaints Ltd.

Want help from application to claim? Compare quotes, then talk to a licensed LifeDirect adviser.

Compare and get quotes

A Simple Checklist for Comparing Life Insurers

A simple way to compare life insurers is to work out how much cover you need, compare prices for your age, check claims records and financial strength, then read the key definitions and exclusions. Checking extras and how claim support works rounds it out. Working through these steps in order keeps the comparison about your needs, not the brand.

  1. Work out how much cover you need: your mortgage, other debts and what your family would need to live on. See how much life insurance you need.
  2. Compare prices for your age and cover amount, and check whether the premium is stepped or level.
  3. Look at claims records and financial strength ratings.
  4. Read the key definitions and exclusions, especially if you have a health condition.
  5. Check extras, such as rewards programmes like AIA Vitality.
  6. Ask how support works if your family ever needs to claim.

An example

Say you're 38, own a home with your partner, have two young children and had asthma as a child. Two insurers might quote similar prices, but one may ask more about your asthma or offer different terms. Checking how each is likely to treat your health history before you apply helps you avoid surprises. A LifeDirect adviser can do this with you for free.

For more on how insurers assess your health, read understanding underwriting in life insurance. If you already have cover, read switching or replacing your insurance before moving it.

Frequently Asked Questions About NZ Life Insurers

Still comparing? A quote is free, takes a few minutes, and shows you prices from eight NZ insurers.

Get Quotes

Which NZ life insurer is right for me?

This is a personal question that depends on individual circumstances. LifeDirect provides factual information and comparisons to help people understand their options. See what people ask us most about life insurance for more.

Which life insurer pays the most claims in NZ?

In dollar terms, AIA, which paid $790 million in claims in 2025. That mostly reflects its size, as New Zealand's largest life insurer.

Which insurer has the highest claims acceptance rate?

Asteron Life, Chubb Life and Partners Life all report around 95% to 97%. Each measures its rate differently and over a different period, so the figures aren't directly comparable.

Is a higher claims acceptance rate always better?

Not on its own. Acceptance rates depend on how claims are counted and which products are included. Policy definitions and the terms you're offered matter just as much.

What matters more than the insurer's brand?

How the policy defines conditions, the terms you're offered for your health, the price for your age and cover, and help at claim time. These decide what the cover is worth to you.

Is Partners Life buying Fidelity Life?

Yes. Partners Life's parent company agreed in September 2026 to buy Fidelity Life, subject to regulator approval. Until the deal completes, the two insurers run separately.

Will my policy change if my insurer is sold?

No. Your policy is a contract, so a change of owner doesn't change what you're covered for or what you pay. Claims carry on as normal.

What is a financial strength rating?

It's an independent agency's view of an insurer's ability to pay claims over time. Agencies such as AM Best, Fitch and S&P each use their own scale.

Can I get life insurance with a health condition?

Often, yes. Depending on the condition, an insurer may offer standard terms, charge more or add an exclusion. Different insurers can treat the same history differently, so comparing before you apply helps.

Is it a good idea to switch insurers for a lower price?

It depends on your circumstances. A new policy is a new application, so a health change since you first applied could mean an exclusion or a higher premium. Many people keep their existing cover until a new policy is accepted.

How many insurers does LifeDirect compare?

LifeDirect compares quotes from eight NZ insurers. You can apply yourself or get free advice from a licensed adviser.

Is LifeDirect free to use?

Yes. LifeDirect is free to use because insurers pay us a commission when you take out a policy, and a smaller ongoing commission each year while it's in place. LifeDirect 2020 Limited is a licensed financial advice provider (FSP724353).

Key Terms, Explained

Term What it means
Claims Acceptance Rate The share of claims an insurer accepts, measured in its own way and over its own period.
Claims Paid The total amount an insurer paid out in claims over a period.
Financial Strength Rating An independent agency's view of an insurer's ability to pay claims over time.
Rating Agency A company such as AM Best, Fitch or S&P that gives financial strength ratings.
Policy Definition The wording that sets out exactly what counts as a covered condition or event.
Standard Terms Cover offered at the normal price, without extra charges or exclusions.
Exclusion Something a policy won't pay for, such as a named pre-existing condition.
Loading An extra amount added to your premium because of a health or lifestyle risk.
Underwriting The insurer's assessment of your health, lifestyle and job before it offers cover.
Stepped Premium A premium that usually rises each year as you get older.
Level Premium A premium that stays the same for a set time, usually starting higher.
Terminal Illness Benefit An early payout of life cover if you're diagnosed with a terminal illness.

Disclaimer: Please note that the content provided in this article is intended as an overview and as general information only. While care is taken to ensure accuracy and reliability, the information provided is subject to continuous change and may not reflect current development or address your situation. Before making any decisions based on the information provided in this article, please use your discretion and seek independent guidance.

Starting a quote takes seconds, get on your way to being prepared for the unexpected.

Get quotes
Disclosure statement Complaints Security & Privacy